Mon-Fri 8am-5pm  ·  Sat 8am-3pm ★ ★ ★ ★ ★   Five-Star Automotive Repair (516) 681-0122
Home/Customer Reviews
5.0 Stars · 235+ Verified Reviews · Google & SureCritic

What Long Island
Says About Us

Over five decades of keeping Nassau County families on the road. 235+ verified reviews across Google and SureCritic, with a 5.0-star rating on both.

5.0
Based on 115+ Google reviews
5 ★
110
4 ★
5
3 ★
0
2 ★
0
1 ★
0

Had a Great Experience?

Your review helps other Garden City drivers find an honest shop they can trust.

Leave a Google Review
Verified Reviews
What Our Customers Say
Happy car owner shaking hands with a mechanic at Broadway Servicenter in Garden City, NY
"

Got an estimate from Lexus for $4,200. Paid $1,700 at Bobby's place. They are the absolute best.

"

Our family has been using Broadway Service Center for over 40 years. True professionals. We always feel confident the job is done right with integrity at a great price.

"

Bobby and his crew are top notch. They treat you like family, and what's more important is that they get the job done right the first time. I would highly recommend them to anyone.

"

Brought my Toyota Camry in for a brake job. They showed me exactly what was worn before touching anything and gave me a price that was hundreds less than the dealer. Honest and fast.

"

AC stopped working in July. They diagnosed it same day, told me it was a failed compressor, and had it fixed by the next morning. My car's AC blows colder than when I bought it. Unbelievable service.

"

Bob personally walked me through what was wrong with my Prius battery system. Saved me a trip to the Toyota dealer and saved me over $800. This place is the real deal. I tell everyone I know.

SureCritic
Verified Reviews
✓ Verified by Service Records

120 More Reviews on SureCritic

SureCritic reviews are different from Google reviews: only customers with confirmed service visits can leave them. They are verified directly against our shop records. No anonymous reviews, no fakes. Broadway Servicenter holds a 5.0-star rating across all 120 of them, with a Net Promoter Score of 98 out of 100.

A Net Promoter Score of 98 means virtually every customer who comes in says they would send a friend or family member here. That number comes directly from post-service surveys SureCritic sends on our behalf.

5.0
★★★★★
Average Rating
120
Verified Reviews
98
Net Promoter Score
96%
Five-Star Reviews
Read All 120 SureCritic Reviews Leave a SureCritic Review

See All Our Reviews on Google

Our full review history is on Google Maps. See what your neighbors in Garden City, Mineola, Westbury, and across Nassau County say about working with Bob and the team.

View All Google Reviews

Ready to Experience It Yourself?

Honest work, fair pricing, and a warranty on every repair. Garden City, NY, since 1967.

Ready to Schedule?
Takes 2 minutes. No obligation.
Schedule Appointment